Monday, July 1, 2013

Super Kmart Center in Cambridge, Ohio

Nicholas Eckhart
nicholas@deadanddyingretail.com


     This time I visited a Super Kmart Center store in Cambridge, Ohio. Let me start off by mentioning that this location is a one of a kind Kmart store; it is the only store of this design to be expanded into a supercenter. I use the word "expanded" for a reason; a few other stores of this design were converted to Super Kmart in 2001, but they were not expanded. Those stores except one in Caguas, Puerto Rico have been closed. Perhaps slamming grocery areas into stores smaller than 100,000 square feet was a bad move on Kmart's part. Currently, the only two Super Kmart stores remaining that are in expanded 1990s stores (the one featured in this post and one in Ashtabula, Ohio that was built with an earlier design in 1991) are both around 150,000 square feet, which is a much more appropriate size for a Super Kmart.

     In the early 2000s Kmart had plans to convert or expand over a thousand Big Kmart stores into the Super Kmart concept as well as build numerous ground-up Super Kmart stores to replace older smaller Kmart stores. After Kmart's bankruptcy in 2002 all stores undergoing an expansion or remodel into a Super Kmart stopped the process and remained operating as Kmart; the best examples of this are stores in Albuquerque, New Mexico and Passaic, New Jersey. No more conversions or expansions would occur after the bankruptcy either. Also, all ground-up Super Center construction projects were cancelled directly after the bankruptcy no matter how close to completion the stores were, but some standard Kmart construction projects continued and were finished such as Bishop, California and Somers Point, New Jersey. The 2002 Super Kmart construction projects with structures still largely intact are in Albuquerque, New Mexico; Milwaukee, Wisconsin; and Mesa, Arizona. 

     One other strike happened to Super Kmart in 2002 when 12 Super Kmart closures were the result of Kmart's bankruptcy. The biggest strike ever to the Super Kmart concept was when 58 Super Kmart stores closed in 2003. Since then 26 stores got rid of their groceries and a number of them closed. As of July 2013 only 23 Super Kmart stores will remain operating.

     The first Kmart in Cambridge, Ohio opened in the very early 1960s as store number 3555 around a mile north of the current Cambridge Kmart site. By the 1990s that store was considered very small and outdated compared with other Kmart stores in Ohio. Ohio was also more or less considered the home base for the Super Kmart concept stores. As a replacement for the old Cambridge store, plans for a Super Kmart Center were drawn and meant to be built on Southgate Parkway just south of interstate 70. However, in the early 1990s Kmart was getting mixed results with their supercenter stores so they began to second guess the concept. As a result Kmart Corp. downsized the plans for this particular store to be built as a larger sized Kmart store. It is unclear how many Super Kmart plans were downsized into regular Kmart stores, but I do know of a few others myself.

     The new Kmart store in Cambridge opened in 1995 at the same site meant to house the supercenter. At over 100,000 square feet this store was one of the largest Kmart stores at the time it was built. The store was built in a way to make a future conversion to a Super Kmart seamless and possibly most likely included a pantry before the Big Kmart era. An area, in a similar fashion as many other stores of this design, was set aside next to the store's entrance; the space would later be utilized in the store's Super Kmart expansion. The original layout included a Kmart Cafe with an attached customer service desk to the right of the entrance plus Layaway, Fitting Rooms and an Olan Mills portrait studio along the side wall.

     In 2001 the Cambridge Kmart was expanded into Super Kmart and also added a prototype Kmart Express gas station and convenience store with an attached Penske Express auto center (the auto center would close about a year later as a result of Penske's bankruptcy). During the conversion the cafe and restrooms in the front were ripped out, along with the fitting rooms, Olan Mills, and layaway. The customer service section along with Olan Mills, the store's offices, and restrooms were moved up front plus Layaway moved to the back of the store when the back was slightly expanded as well. Since then the Olan Mills Portrait studio in this store closed. This store is 148,527 square feet now that it has been expanded.

     I was overly impressed with the design of the Cambridge store on my visit. It is very hard to tell the store was built as a Kmart on the inside except for only one main entrance being present into the store. The conversion of this store seems very well thought out and not haphazard like the conversion of the Ashtabula store is. The staff seemed friendly at this location and it was very clean, well lit, well maintained, and more updated than many Kmart or Super Kmart stores I have been. The Cambridge store does not have a Little Caesar's pizza like many other ones, but the Little Caesar's existing restaurant in the shopping center has to be the reason why. I notice that many photographers have taken one or two pictures of the exterior of this store while passing through; I believe I am the first photographer to venture inside this store and take pictures of it. Enjoy the pictures of this one of a kind store!

Here are some exterior photos of the store

The 24 Hours part of the sign is whited out from the store's brief time as being open from 6 am to 12 am. Now the store is open 24 hours again.

The garden center entrance

The refrigeration units are visible on top of the store.
The section of the store with the lights is the part added in 2001. The expansion does not connect to the rest of the shopping center.
Below are pictures of the Kmart Express / Penske Express building


The doors are for the Penske Express location


The Kmart logo fell off this sign and exposed some white neon underneath.
This was the lobby for the Penske Express, it is now part of the convenience store.



Now on to the interior of the store...


Produce is up front, the fake wood tiles mark where the Cafe was originally.
Customer service and restrooms would have been in this area originally.
The main entrance / exit to the store.
Customer Service was moved here after the conversion. The other door is where the Olan Mills Portrait Studio used to be.


Deli and Bakery
A reintroduction of floral items at this location.
The produce section
Looking from the front of the store towards the back the square poles mark the general area of the original side wall.
A frozen foods aisle.
Super Kmart logo spotted despite the fact this store has the Super Kmart Center signage.




Seafood and Fresh Meat




Fresh Meat. The squares in the ceiling function as part of the refrigeration system.












The back wall of the sales floor remains unmodified from when the store opened.






This Layaway section was added to the back of the store. There are no restrooms back here like in most Kmart or Super Kmart stores.












The red triangle marks the location of a fire extinguisher and is a remnant of the original wall decor of this location.




Checkouts
Island style fitting rooms that were added when the store was converted.

Here is the store that was replaced by the current Cambridge store in 1995.


A very old Kmart facade remains on this store!



The former Garden Center

A possible  former Kmart Foods store

Thank You for visiting Dead and Dying retail!

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

North Towne Square Mall in Toledo, Ohio

Nicholas Eckhart


     There was a massive dead mall lying just a few thousand feet south of the Ohio and Michigan state-line on the north side of Toledo. Unfortunately for the people who would like to pay a visit to this dead mall themselves, it has since been demolished. The pictures in this post were taken a week or two before North Towne Square was turned into a pile of debris. All that currently remains on site is the Wards store, (now operates as Super Fitness and Darla & Co.), a former Pier 1 Imports that is being reused as AAA, and a Toys R Us store on an out-parcel.

     The original plans for the mall called for it to be developed by Phillip Portteus and to be called Skyview National Plaza. Later Simon Property Group took over the site and started planning a new mall called North Towne Square that would have 850,000 square feet of space. The actual square footage of the mall would be 735,000. North Towne Square was intended to have four anchor stores, but only Mongomery Ward, The Lion Store, and Lasalle's signed to Simon and built stores at the site. The mall was created since Simon figured they could be supported by the northeast part of Toledo and towns in southeast Michigan like Monroe. 

     The Lion store and Lasalle's opened in 1980 while the interior part of the mall and Mongomery Ward opened in March 1981. The mall featured many big name smaller stores in its original tenant line-up such as McCrory, Radio Shack, CVS, Claire's, Stride Rite, and an AMC movie theater. North Towne Square had a pretty big volume business in its early years. In the Mall's early years Lasalle's changed its name to Macy's and then was acquired by Elder Beerman. The first major blow to business came in 1988 when Frenchtown Square Mall (now called The Mall of Monroe) opened in Monroe, Michigan. Frenchtown featured five anchor stores including an Elder Beerman. Another hit to North Towne came in 1993 when nearby Franklin Park mall expanded and included added a store that North Towne Square also had : The Lion Store.

     The Elder Beerman store was closed in 1997, leaving a mall built for four anchor stores with only two. In 1998 Dillard's acquired and re branded the Lion Store as Dillard's. Dillard's closed in 2000 due to poor sales. At that point stores were fleeing North Towne square at a dreadfully fast rate. The chain stores left first and set up in other malls nearby such as Frenchtown and Franklin Park and more stores in the mall  became family run. Montgomery Ward closed their remaining stores in 2002, leaving North Towne with no remaining anchor stores. Right after Wards closed Simon bailed on the mall and opted to sell the property to two people from California. The new owners "officially" changed the name of North Towne Square to Lakeside Centre, but left most of the North Towne Square signage up. The change in ownership drew in new stores such as MC Sports and Bath & Body Works, but those stores quickly bailed as well. Late in 2003 Super Fitness opened in the former Ward's store. 
     
     North Towne Square (Lakeside Centre) was closed in July 2005. The mall was demolished in January 2013. Currently Super Fitness, Darla & Co. Toys R Us, and AAA are the only businesses on the property.      




This was originally York Steakhouse






The Lion Store
This store operated as The Lion Store from 1980 to 1998 and Dillard's from 1998 to 2000.

















Montgomery Ward 
This store relocated in 1981 from Greenwood Mall (became a strip mall after North Towne Square opened) and remained operating until the Wards chain closed all their stores in 2002. Mongomery Ward was the only anchor at North Towne Square that did not get acquired and renamed. Currently, Super Fitness and Darla & Co. hair salon & day spa use part of this store. The Auto Center and the north side of the store remain unused. There is a picture on another site of the store with the signage still up. http://tch546.tripod.com/genret/index.html


The North side of the Wards store.




Notice that there are Wards stickers on the doors.
A sign left behind by Wards



Darla & Co. is on the West side of the former Wards.

Super Fitness is located in the south half of the former Montgomery Wards store.









Lasalle's
This store was opened as a Lasalle's in 1980 despite other sources that say this opened as Hudson's. In 1982 this store was converted to R.H. Macy & Co. along with the other stores in the Lasalle's chain. Elder Beerman purchased this store from R.H. Macy & Co. in 1984. In 1997 Elder Beerman shuttered this location and it has remained vacant since.













Toys R Us
This is the last store left operating in the area.


The lack of cars is not a good sign.






Kids R Us sign (taken from a closed store perhaps?)





Pier 1 Imports
 This store is currently used as a AAA facility.




The mystery sign...
Not really a mystery, North Towne Square went by the name Lakeside Center from 2003 until the mall closed in 2005. Oddly enough, the mall entrances still displayed the name North Towne Square until the mall's closure.